- Family reunion appeal allowed on the spot before Judge O’Hagan in Birmingham on pure Article 8 ECHR despite conceding the appellant does not meet the requirements of 352A-352FA. Previous adverse Devaseelan findings overturned and AT (Article 8 ECHR – Family Reunification) Eritrea [2016] UKUT 227 distinguished. I appeared for the appellant with andy akhuetie, LLM instructing.